Blog

The CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series, Autumn 2024: Online talk by Prof. Ilanah Fhima on Innovative Methods

Posted on    by
BlogTrade Mark Seminar Series

The CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series, Autumn 2024: Online talk by Prof. Ilanah Fhima on Innovative Methods

By 21 November 2024March 4th, 2025No Comments

We are delighted to announce the first online event in the CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series, Autumn 2024, focusing on innovative methodologies in researching current trade mark law.

SEMINAR 1: INNOVATIVE METHODOLOGIES IN RESEARCHING CURRENT TRADE MARK LAW

Time and place: Thursday, 21st November 2024, 2pm to 3pm UK time, online.

Speaker: Prof. Ilanah Fhima, Institute of Brand and Innovation Law, UCL.

Chair: Dr Xiaoren Wang, CREATe Fellow and University of Dundee.

Title: Foreign language trade marks: the less than average consumer.

Abstract: In this presentation, I will focus on the empirical element of this study. We are used to viewing trade mark law through the eyes of the average consumer. There are good reasons for this rooted in the consumer protection justification for trade mark law. However, the UK ‘average’ consumer (as the term is understood in common parlance) is very much a monoglot. In this study I consider theoretical and practical reasons why we should not limit ourselves to the conventional meaning of ‘average’ and why it is crucial to consider the meaning of minority languages of trade mark decisions. I also consider, using doctrinal and empirical analysis, the extent to which trade mark law can take into account these considerations, focussing on particular the average consider is defined under UK law. The picture is a mixed one: I identify concerns about consistency but also a growing consensus (including in the recent Supreme Court Amazon v Lifestyle decision) on a more subtle approach to how we understand the average consumer not as a majority or hypothetic individual but rather as a corpus of different yet significant groups of consumers with different understanding of the world. That said, there is still a way to go as the Registry to date has been reticent to recognise speakers of foreign languages as ‘significant’ groups for these purposes. This has negative effects both at the level of rhetoric, but also in relation to the possibility of monopolising terms which are descriptive in other languages.

Biography: Ilanah Fhima is Professor of Intellectual Property Law at University College London (UCL) and Co-Director of the UCL Institute of Brand and Innovation Law. She has published widely on trade marks, including books (both published by Oxford University Press) on likelihood of confusion and on dilution. Her recent research, which investigates the registration of shape marks, has been featured in US and UK academic and professional journals. Her current research focusses on language rights, the average consumer and the interaction between diversity and trade mark law. Ilanah has worked with or presented for various professional bodies and organisations including WIPO, EUIPO, MARQUES and INTA.

As previously announced, the CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series comprises two on-line talks about trade mark law each term: one on trade mark history (convened by Dr Elena Cooper), and one on innovative methodologies in trade mark research (convened by Dr Xiaoren Wang). The Series was launched in Summer 2022. It is open to scholars (including research students) of any discipline worldwide.

Zoom links for the seminars will be emailed a few days before the events to all on the CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series mailing list. There is no need to RSVP. To join the mailing list, please contact Elena Cooper: elena.cooper@glasgow.ac.uk

Stay tuned for more news from CREATe fellows and our upcoming events by subscribing to our newsletter.