We are delighted to announce the continuation of the CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series, Summer 2024, with an online talk focusing on innovative methodologies in researching current trade mark law by Dr Xiaoren Wang with commentator Prof. Barton Beebe.
SEMINAR 2: INNOVATIVE METHODOLOGIES IN RESEARCHING CURRENT TRADE MARK LAW
Time and place: Thursday, 6th June 2024, 2pm to 3pm UK time, online.
Speaker: Dr Xiaoren Wang, CREATe Fellow/University of Dundee.
Commentator: Prof. Barton Beebe, NYU School of Law.
Chair: Dr Elena Cooper, Senior Research Fellow, CREATe.
Title: Should we Worry about Colour Depletion? An Empirical Study of USPTO Single-Colour Trade Mark Registrations.
Abstract: Trade mark law across the US, EU and UK permits the registration of single colours as trade marks. However, some judges and experts have raised concerns about this law, known as the colour depletion theory, which argues that it could deplete the pool of available colours for use as trade marks. This theory suggests that trademarking single colours raises several issues. It creates market entry barriers. As more single colours are claimed as trade marks, there are fewer colour options left for new entrants. Moreover, colour depletion leads to increased consumer search costs. When more single colours are claimed as trade marks, the distances between colours shrink and the boundaries between colour trade marks are blurred. Thereby consumers are more likely confused by similar colour trade marks. Despite extensive theoretical debates on colour depletion, this article is the first empirical study that investigates whether in reality colour depletion is severe or ignorable. This article examines 858 single-colour trade marks recorded in the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). It is the first quantitative research which uses Python program to examine the scale and distribution of depletion across different colours and product/service classes. It analyses (1) the existing colour depletion percentage in each product/service class, and (2) how soon each product/service class will reach full depletion, and (3) the distribution of depletion in different colour areas (hue segments). Based on this data analysis, the article concludes that colour depletion is an emergent concern in certain product/service classes including electric and technological products (Class 9), medical instruments (Class 10), etc which are likely to be fully depleted by 2050. Moreover, many colour trade marks are concentrated in the red (hue 246-15), orange (hue 16-25, 46-55), yellow (hue 56-65) and green (hue 96-155) segments in Classes 7, 9, 10, 11 and 35. The finding partially proves the colour depletion theory. Based on this finding, the article further provides recommendations to the USPTO/courts to address colour depletion and calls for re-checking the ‘first-possession’ trade mark system.
Biographies:
Xiaoren Wang is a lecturer in IP law at the University of Dundee and a research fellow at CREATe. She focuses on empirical research on IP issues including trade marks, copyright and digital platforms. She is also interested in the law and economic analysis in the fields of IP law and frontier technologies. Xiaoren graduated from the University of Illinois. After that, she worked as a post-doctoral Global Fellow at NYU and the European University Institute (EUI) as well as an academic visitor at the University of Oxford. She currently serves as the Cyberlaw convenor of the Society of Legal Scholar (SLS), hosts the CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series and co-leads the Scottish Law and Innovation Network (SCOTLIN).
Barton Beebe is the John M. Desmarais Professor of Intellectual Property Law at NYU School of Law and a Co-Director of the Engelberg Center on Innovation Law & Policy at NYU. He specializes in the doctrinal, empirical, and cultural analysis of intellectual property law. He has been the James S. Carpentier Visiting Professor of Law at Columbia Law School, the Anne Urowsky Visiting Professor of Law at Yale Law School, the Cheng Yu Tung Visiting Professor at The University of Hong Kong Faculty of Law, a Visiting Professor of Law at Stanford Law School, and a Visiting Research Fellow at Merton College, Oxford. He is the author of Trademark Law: An Open-Source Casebook, a free digital trademark law textbook used in numerous law schools around the world.
As previously announced, the CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series comprises two on-line talks about trade mark law each term: one on trade mark history (convened by Dr Elena Cooper), and one on innovative methodologies in trade mark research (convened by Dr Xiaoren Wang). The Series was launched in Summer 2022. It is open to scholars (including research students) of any discipline worldwide.
Zoom links for the seminars will be emailed a few days before the events to all on the CREATe Trade Mark Seminar Series mailing list. There is no need to RSVP. To join the mailing list, please contact Elena Cooper: elena.cooper@glasgow.ac.uk